Regarding Item #14, Adoption of Civic Center Vision and Implementation Plan--an open letter to the Berkeley City Council
I am writing to strongly recommend that you not take final action to adopt a single “Vision” for the Civic Center at your Tuesday, September 22, 2020 meeting but instead hold a workshop to hear a presentation of the current staff and consultant recommendations, thank the consultants for their work so their contracts can be wrapped up, and move to the next stage which should be review of the proposed “Vision” by three or four Commissions and opportunity for general public review and comment.
The proposal should certainly go for comments to the full Landmarks Preservation Commission and the full Parks & Waterfront Commission, both of which share jurisdiction over review and advising on buildings and facilities in the Civic Center area.
It should also probably go to the Public Works Commission—since it involves changes to two streets, and infrastructure—and to the Civic Arts Commission, since a major array of performing and visual arts facilities is proposed for the Civic Center.
The “Vision” can then come back to the Council at a future date for possible action. That should probably be about three or four months from now. By that time Federal and State elections will also be over and at least the broad parameters of the state and national economic and political situation will be clearer, with all their implications for municipal budgets and funding and opportunities for—or roadblocks to—civic improvements.
You have been told that the final “Vision” went through a robust community process and is ready for your action. This is not correct or accurate.
The reality is that the actual public process involved review of three options, while the final recommended “Vision” was only released publicly this month, incorporated into a more than 900 page report, with supplemental documents and reports. There has been no meaningful opportunity for Commissions, the general public, other stakeholders like community groups (in preservation and the arts in particular) or even Councilmembers for that matter, to review, digest, react to, and consider all this material.
-more-